California Limits Mandatory Arbitration Agreements Where The FAA Does Not Apply
A recent California Court of Appeal decision creates an important distinction for employers using mandatory arbitration agreements in California. In Molina v. Triumph Residential Services, Inc., the court held that when an employment arbitration agreement is not governed by the Federal Arbitration Act (the “FAA”), California Labor Code section 432.6 (“Section 432.6”) prohibits an employer from requiring an employee to enter into the agreement as a condition of employment. An agreement formed in violation of that prohibition may be unenforceable under California law.
The decision does not generally prohibit mandatory employment arbitration agreements in California. Where the FAA applies, the Ninth Circuit has held that Section 432.6 is preempted by federal law. Instead, Molina addresses the less common - but potentially significant - circumstance in which the FAA does not apply and California law governs the agreement.
California’s Restriction on Mandatory Arbitration Agreements
Section 432.6 generally prohibits employers from requiring an applicant or employee, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or receipt of an employment-related benefit, to waive a right, forum, or procedure for claims arising under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act or Labor Code. It also provides that an agreement requiring an employee to affirmatively opt out of a waiver to preserve those rights is deemed a condition of employment.
Section 432.6 contains an important exception, however: it expressly states that it is not intended to invalidate a written arbitration agreement that is otherwise enforceable under the FAA. In Chamber of Commerce v. Bonta, the Ninth Circuit held that the FAA preempts Section 432.6’s restrictions on the formation of arbitration agreements. Thus, for FAA-covered agreements, California generally cannot prohibit an employer from requiring arbitration merely because the agreement is a condition of employment.
The FAA generally applies to written arbitration agreements in contracts “involving commerce,” a requirement courts interpret broadly. As a result, the FAA governs most employment arbitration agreements, provided the employment relationship has a sufficient connection to interstate commerce. However, the Molina decision addresses agreements that fall outside these categories, where California law alone governs.
The Molina Decision
In Molina, a Los Angeles-based company provided its employee, Molina, with an arbitration agreement as part of the hiring process. The agreement required disputes to be resolved through binding arbitration and included waivers of class and representative claims. Although the agreement stated that the parties entered it “freely and voluntarily,” the employer conceded that Molina’s options were to accept the agreement, attempt to negotiate out of it, or look for other employment.
Molina subsequently filed a class action alleging various wage-and-hour violations, and the employer sought to compel arbitration. The trial court held that the arbitration agreement was unenforceable, concluding that it was not governed by the FAA and violated Section 432.6 by requiring arbitration as a condition of employment.
The Court of Appeal affirmed. The court reasoned that Section 432.6’s exception applies only to arbitration agreements “otherwise enforceable under the FAA.” Where an agreement violates Section 432.6 and is not enforceable under the FAA, the employer may not enforce an arbitration agreement that is made a condition of employment. The court emphasized that its decision did not determine when the FAA applies or the broader scope of FAA preemption; the parties had already agreed that the FAA did not govern their agreement.
Calling an Agreement “Voluntary” Is Not Enough
Molina also provides an important reminder about how employers present arbitration agreements. The employer argued that the agreement was voluntary because it stated that Molina signed it “freely and voluntarily.” However, the court looked beyond that language to the circumstances surrounding execution of the agreement. In particular, the court rejected the argument that Molina was free to sign the agreement or “look for other employment,” reasoning that those choices effectively made signing the agreement a condition of employment. Accordingly, where the FAA does not apply, merely describing an agreement as voluntary may not be sufficient.
What Employers Should Do Now
In light of Molina, California employers using arbitration agreements should consider the following steps:
- Review whether the FAA applies. Employers should review existing arbitration agreements and the circumstances of their workforce to determine whether the agreements are governed by the FAA. Where FAA coverage exists, agreements should clearly identify the FAA as the governing law.
- Review agreements that may fall outside the FAA. If an arbitration agreement is not governed by the FAA, employers should not make execution of the agreement a condition of hiring, continued employment, or receipt of an employment-related benefit.
- Make any voluntary process genuinely voluntary. For agreements governed solely by California law, employers should consider expressly stating that signing the arbitration agreement is not a condition of employment. Employers should also review onboarding practices to ensure that agreements are presented consistently with those representations.
- Avoid relying solely on opt-out procedures. Section 432.6 expressly provides that requiring an employee to opt out or take affirmative action to preserve the right to proceed in court constitutes a condition of employment. Employers should therefore carefully review opt-out mechanisms for agreements not covered by the FAA.
- Preserve FAA arguments when enforcement becomes necessary. Where an employer seeks to compel arbitration, the applicability of the FAA may now be particularly important. Employers and counsel should develop the factual and legal basis for FAA coverage early rather than assuming that the agreement's enforceability will be determined solely under California law.
Key Takeaway
Molina does not eliminate mandatory employment arbitration agreements in California, but it makes the source of law governing those agreements increasingly important. Where the FAA applies, federal preemption continues to provide significant protection for mandatory arbitration agreements. Where the FAA does not apply, however, Molina establishes that an employer cannot require arbitration of covered California employment claims as a condition of employment.
California employers should review their arbitration programs to confirm whether the FAA governs, ensure that agreements appropriately address applicable law, and identify any categories of employees or agreements that may fall outside the FAA. For those agreements, employers should evaluate both the language of the agreement and the onboarding process to ensure that arbitration is voluntary. For more information or assistance, please contact one of Honigman's Employment and Labor Attorneys here.
Related Professionals
- Elaina Bailey
- Brett Bonfanti
- Sean Crotty
- Michelle Crockett
- Mary Kathryn Curry
- Michael Dauphinais
- Matthew Disbrow
- D'Antae Gooden
- Sara Jodoin
- Jennifer Muse
- Matthew Radler
- James Reid, IV
- Matthew Ritzman, Ph.D.
- Rana Roumayah
- Ryan Stults
- Haba Yono
- Marilyn Yousif
- Tristyn Walton
- LaZaurea Williams
- Mahja Zeon
Related Services
Media Contact
To request an interview or find a speaker, please contact: press@honigman.com