Fair Chance Hiring Obligations Continue to Expand Across Jurisdictions

Alert

Fair chance hiring obligations continue to expand across jurisdictions, requiring employers to navigate an increasingly complex patchwork of restrictions on the use of criminal history in employment decisions. Building on our July 28, 2026 Client Alert regarding amendments to Washington’s Fair Chance Act, recent developments in San Francisco and Virginia further illustrate this trend and provide an opportunity for employers to review their background check and hiring practices.

San Francisco Expands its Fair Chance Obligations

San Francisco recently amended its Fair Chance Ordinance (“FCO”) to further restrict the criminal history that covered employers may consider when making employment decisions. The FCO generally applies to employers with five or more employees and regulates the use of criminal history for positions involving work in San Francisco. 

Under amendments that took effect on August 10, 2026, employers may not inquire about, require disclosure of, or base an adverse employment action in whole or in part on an out-of-state conviction or unresolved arrest involving conduct that is lawful in California and relates to (i) abortion-related healthcare; (ii) drag performances; (iii) gender-affirming care; or (iv) spontaneous abortion.  These restrictions apply even where the conduct resulted in a criminal record in another jurisdiction. Accordingly, employers conducting multistate background checks should not assume that a conviction or arrest appearing on a report may be considered simply because the underlying conduct was unlawful where it occurred.

The amendments also strengthen San Francisco’s existing adverse-action requirements. Before taking adverse action based on criminal history, an employer must provide notice of the proposed action and identify the criminal history on which it intends to rely. If an applicant or employee timely provides information challenging the accuracy of the record or offering evidence of rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances, the employer must consider that information before making a final decision.

Virginia Expands Protections for Sealed Criminal Records

Virginia has also expanded protections for applicants with sealed criminal records under its Clean Slate framework.  As of July 1, 2026, Virginia generally prohibits state and local government employers, educational institutions, and private employers that are not otherwise subject to federal hiring laws or regulations from requiring applicants to disclose arrests, charges, or convictions that have been sealed. Applicants may omit sealed criminal history when responding to questions concerning prior arrests, charges, or convictions.

Employers that ask applicants about criminal history generally must also inform applicants that they are not required to disclose records that have been sealed. The law includes certain exceptions, including where state or federal law requires disclosure or where particular positions are subject to separate background-check or national-security requirements.

Employers operating in Virginia should therefore review employment applications, interview materials, and other criminal-history inquiries to ensure that they do not improperly seek information concerning sealed records. 

What Employers Should Do Now

Employers with operations in San Francisco or Virginia should consider taking the following steps:

  • Review criminal background check policies and decision-making criteria. San Francisco employers should confirm that prohibited out-of-state records are not considered in employment decisions.
  • Evaluate adverse-action procedures. Employers covered by San Francisco’s FCO should ensure that applicants and employees receive the required notices and opportunities to provide additional information before a final adverse decision is made.
  • Review Virginia applications and interview materials. Employers should ensure that applicants are not required to disclose sealed criminal history and that any required notice regarding sealed records is incorporated into the hiring process.
  • Confirm applicable exceptions. Employers subject to federal hiring requirements, national-security obligations, or other industry-specific background-check mandates should determine whether an exception applies before requesting otherwise protected information.
  • Coordinate with background screening vendors. Employers should confirm that vendors can appropriately identify or suppress criminal-history information that may not lawfully be considered.

Key Takeaway

The San Francisco and Virginia developments reflect the continued expansion of state and local restrictions on employers’ use of criminal history. For multistate employers, a uniform background screening process may no longer adequately account for differing jurisdictional requirements regarding what criminal-history information may be requested, considered, or used in an employment decision. Employers should periodically review their hiring and background check procedures to ensure that those practices account for the jurisdictions in which applicants and employees are located and that hiring personnel and screening vendors understand the applicable restrictions. For more information or assistance, please contact one of Honigman's Employment and Labor Attorneys here.

Related Services

Jump to Page

Media Contact

To request an interview or find a speaker, please contact: press@honigman.com

Necessary Cookies

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Analytical Cookies

Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.