Federal Circuit Clarifies Its Law on Inoperable Prior Art Combinations

Alert

On November 13, the Federal Circuit issued a precedential decision in In re Netlist, Inc. (No. 25-1286), providing an important clarification on when the inoperability of a prior art combination matters for nonobviousness.

The claimed invention (U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417 and 9,858,215) involves alleged improvements to computer memory architecture that employs chip-select signals and circuitry serving as a buffer between the memory devices and the computer memory controller.

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (Board) found Netlist’s patent claims obvious in view of the combination of Perego (U.S. Patent No. 7,363,422) and a known JEDEC memory architecture. Perego discloses the claimed buffer circuitry but employs a Rambus memory architecture, which does not employ chip-select signals. The JEDEC architecture standard employs the claimed chip-select signals. The Board found there was a motivation to combine Perego and the JEDEC standard because (i) Perego described its configurations as being flexible to accommodate a variety of module configurations and (ii) the JEDEC standard was the dominant architecture used in memory modules at the time.

Netlist appealed, arguing there was no motivation to combine because modifying Perego with the JEDEC standard would render the Perego modules inoperative for their stated purpose. Indeed, such a modification would eliminate the benefits of the Rambus architecture specifically disclosed in Perego.

The Federal Circuit rejected this argument, reiterating that the relevant inquiry when determining obviousness is whether there would have been a motivation to combine prior art disclosures to achieve the claimed invention. Whether the prior art system so modified would still work for its intended purpose does not control the obviousness analysis. The court explained that the inoperability of an alleged prior art combination is relevant in only two limited circumstances: (1) when one of the prior art references supplies the motivation to combine or (2) when one of the prior art references has a purpose that is shared with the challenged claims.

The claimed invention was not limited to improving a memory module having the benefits derived from the Rambus architecture disclosed in Perego. Consequently, the elimination of the Rambus architecture from the Perego module in the combination was not relevant to the motivation to combine issue. The Federal Circuit therefore affirmed the obviousness of all challenged claims.

Take-Away

When inoperability is raised in the context of a prior art combination, it is important to assess whether the inoperability falls within one of the limited circumstances identified in In re Netlist. Moreover, this decision may provide an incentive for a defendant to identify a motivation to combine that lies outside the teachings and purpose of the prior art references when challenging the validity of a patent.

Related Professionals

Jump to Page

Media Contact

To request an interview or find a speaker, please contact: press@honigman.com

Necessary Cookies

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Analytical Cookies

Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.